Ethics discussion questions on AWAKENINGS
1. How do we know that the catatonic patients are 'in there' in a morally relevant sense? Several
terms are used frequently throughout the film as though they indicate moral relevance: (a)
patients are described as merely 'asleep', (b) they are described as being 'in there' (as though they
have 'locked-in syndrome'), (c) they are described as merely lacking 'will'... but that they can still
meaningfully participate in the world if they 'borrow the will' of something or someone else (for
example, by grabbing a moving object, or being steered to walk by a nurse).
2. Note the following conversation between Dr. Sayer (played by Robin Williams) and the
elderly doctor Peter Ingham (played by Max von Sydow) as they watch historical film footage
featuring some of the survivors of the Encephalitis epidemic of the 1920s and 1930s
Dr. Ingham: I began to see them in the early 1930’s…I referred them to psychiatrists. Before
long they were being referred back to me. They could no longer dress themselves or feed
themselves. They could no longer speak in most cases. Families went mad. People who were
normal, were now…elsewhere.
Dr. Sayer: What must it be like to be them? What are they thinking?
Dr. Ingham: They’re not. The virus didn’t spare the higher faculties.
Dr. Sayer: We know that for a fact?
Dr. Ingham: Yes.
Dr. Sayer: Because….?
Dr. Ingham: Because the alternative is unthinkable.
How should we think about persons in catatonic states? How do we determine whether or not
they are able to even register our attempts at communication? What do we owe to persons in
such a state in terms of their rights to care? What if people require artificial life supports to
continue living? Who decides if and how and under what circumstances to continue or not to
continue providing care for them?
3. Note the following conversation between Dr. Sayer and Mrs. Lowe (Leonard’s mother):
Dr. Sayer: Does he ever speak to you?
  • The Awakening: Edna's
    life to music, rather than a man. Edna oscillates between the two identities until she awakens to the fact that she needs to be an individual, but encounters the...
  • The Awakening: Edna
    want to trample upon the little lives." (Chopin, 629). In the title of "The Awakening" I get the impression of someone waking up and deciding that their life is not...
  • Grapes Of Wrath: Awakening Of Tom Joad
    live their life, they would be forced to do so under a united cause. Tom's awakening came slowly as he struggled to understand the toils of needing, not only to care...
  • Kate Chopin's The Awakening
    she really is. Ross C. Murfin in his critical essay "The New Historicism and the Awakening", shows how Chopin uses the entity of the hand to relate to both the...
  • The Awakening: Chopin Glorifying Edna's Fatal Situation
    : Chopin Glorifying Edna's Fatal Situation The title, The Awakening, implies that a rebirth from a stupor into self- awareness is something good. One would...